The documents represent the negative outlook on trade over time, while the Islamic community had views that shifted over time. A merchant who has no direct correlation to these religions, or who is a part of another religion, could provide an important insight through documents such as entries in a journal on what merchants actually receive when trading.
However, over time, the thoughts on trade and merchants shifted to a more negative point of view from both religions. The document describes a strongly negative point of view on the position of trade and merchants in the Muslim community through these various insults and statements.
This document is also filled with point of view because it is written about St. Also, to be more specific, another religion would also be useful to give an idea about how different religions, like Buddhism, reacted and how they felt towards merchants. Godric, who was of course, by an individual who is respected.
This shows a positive movement from document 1 because this document actually talks about the merchant aspiring to get something done and this supports it. Like another similar document, document 7 also addresses unfair trade.
Furthermore, document 5 provides negative viewpoints on the tradesmen because of their goal to search for profit. Love is not any of the gifts, activities or behaviors that companies market to you.
Jesus, the holy leader of the Christian community, was poor, thus his negative views against wealthy merchants could correlate with his inability to receive wealth.
Muslim views began positively and ended negatively, but finished with a positive outlook. The letters also share the same belief that charitable wealth should be distribute among the society through various ways, such as religious paintings or murals to help strengthen the society as a whole.
Chalked says that even though trade is a natural means of livelihood, most services re tricks aimed to make a profit, which leans toward decline in the future. The only religious statement in document 4 discusses the morality of man, which is neither positive nor negative in relation to trade and merchants in the Christian community.
Documents 3 and 4 are also negative, but remain unchanged in the Christian society, whereas the Muslim viewpoint changed over time. It says that no man should sell a thing to another man for than how much it is really worth.
As time passed, Christians began to believe trade was good, Islam stayed constant. More essays like this: Godric is a saint recognized by the church because he helped with his wealth acquired by being a merchant.
This would allow two similar court decisions to be able to be compared to in order to decipher a valid opinion, which could be possible in a political way. Overall, documents 3 and 4 both have similar negative viewpoints on trade and merchant activity. Islam kept their belief and positive influence on trade from C.
Many resources are prejudice and an average Muslim or Christian may not think the same as the book, but most feel obligated to agree because of their religion.Ap World Dbq: Attitudes of Christianity and Islam Toward Merchants Words | 3 Pages.
16, AP World DBQ From the onset of the Christian and Islamic religions, until aboutthe two religions began with two different opinions of merchants, but grew together as time went on.
DBQ Muslims V. Christian Merchants Essay Sample In the beginning of Christianity, trade was considered sinful, while the Muslims thought trade was a lesson of appreciation and hard work. Christians had a strongly negative attitude towards the interaction between trade and merchants.
DBQ CHRISTIAN AND MUSLIM RELIGIOUS VIEWS DIRECTIONS: Write an essay that: 1. Has a relevant thesis and supports that thesis with evidence from the documents. 2. Uses all or all but one of the documents. Takes into account both the sources of the documents and the author' point of view.
5. You may refer to relevant historical information. Christian Muslim View Essay. DBQ Essay: Christian Muslim View of Merchant During the Post-Classical Era merchants played a key role in the foundations of societies - Christian Muslim View Essay introduction.
In its origins, Christianity viewed merchants negatively, whereas Islam saw the profession more positively, reflected in their religious documents; the two religions changed their views.
Ap World History DBQ Christianity Essay Sample. When thinking about the history of the world, one must always consider that merchants as well as trade have played.
DBQ Essay: Christian Muslim View of Merchant During the Post-Classical Era merchants played a key role in the foundations of societies. In its origins, Christianity viewed merchants negatively, whereas Islam saw the profession more positively, reflected in their religious documents; the two religions changed their views byChristianity.Download